Experts Puzzled on Japan's Resilient Real Estate Performance while Struggling with Pandemic Recovery

08 July, 2021 –

In the developed world, the post-pandemic recovery is proceeding apace. In the United States, 46 per cent of the population are fully vaccinated, the rate of expansion in the manufacturing and services sectors is close to a historic high and a key measure of core inflation increased at its fastest rate in nearly 30 years last month. Even in the euro zone, whose recovery is less advanced and which initially struggled with its vaccine roll-out, business activity is growing at its quickest pace in 15 years as economies reopen and immunisation programmes accelerate sharply.
In Japan, however, the recovery is struggling to gain traction.

Survey data published last week showed that private-sector activity was in contraction territory at the end of June, dragged down by a resurgence in Covid-19 infections that forced the government to impose a state of emergency in the biggest cities. While the restrictions have just been eased, fears that next month’s summer Olympic Games in Tokyo could cause a much sharper spike in cases have led to a public outcry over the government’s decision to go ahead with the event.

 In the US and Europe, the return to normality means growth and a withdrawal of monetary stimulus. In Japan, it means a continuation of deflationary pressures and ultra-loose monetary policy. Just as worryingly, Japan is lagging far behind on vaccinations, with only 9 per cent of the population fully inoculated. Yet, while Asia’s largest advanced economy may be missing out on the dramatic rebound in the developed world, it has been one of the most resilient and best-performing real estate investment markets since the pandemic erupted.

In the first quarter of this year, Tokyo was the world’s second-most-actively-traded property investment market at the city level after Boston, accounting for nearly US$8 billion in transaction volumes, having ranked third for the whole of 2020, data from JLL shows. Just as impressively, the share of overseas investment last year reached 34 per cent, the highest proportion since 2007, and an even more remarkable ratio, given that Japan is one of the markets in Asia, along with China and South Korea, where the domestic share of property investment is the highest. Despite virus-induced concerns over the future demand for office space, offices accounted for 52 per cent of investment deals in Japan in the first quarter, on a par with pre-pandemic levels, according to JLL. Although rents in Tokyo are under pressure, net absorption of office space last year was even higher than in 2019, helping keep the city’s vacancy rate under 2 per cent.

Christian Mancini, chief executive for Asia-Pacific (excluding Greater China) at Savills in Tokyo, says the strong performance of Japan’s property investment market suggests bleak headline-grabbing economic data has little bearing on investor sentiment. “It has all of us staring at each other and scratching our heads,” he said. Other country-specific factors, however, help explain why real estate investors are drawn to Japan.

First, no other market in Asia has the liquidity and stability Japan offers. Not only does the country typically account for the largest share of annual transaction volumes in the region, it has long been perceived as a safe haven, underpinned by political stability, a relatively high level of market transparency and a large pool of core properties with creditworthy tenants. Second, although foreign investors face stiff competition from a well-established local institutional investor base, the strength of domestic capital makes Japan’s property market more resilient to external shocks. It also adds depth to the sector, providing a solid foundation for overseas investors to achieve scale. 
Third, the investment market is broadening out, with buyers looking beyond Tokyo. Osaka, Japan’s second-largest city, was the world’s 15th-most-widely-traded property market in the first quarter, while the Greater Osaka, Nagoya and Fukuoka regions together accounted for a quarter of deals in Japan last year, compared with 12 per cent in 2010, data from JLL shows. Fourth, the maturity of Japan’s real estate market, and its ample liquidity, are particularly advantageous in the logistics and multifamily sectors, the two most popular asset classes since the pandemic erupted. 

Japan accounted for 39 per cent of logistics deals in Asia last year, according to property consultant RCA, with investors increasingly drawn to larger regional cities. Yet, it is the appeal of Japan’s rental housing sector that explains a lot about the strong performance of the country’s property market. By far the largest in Asia, and one of the most liquid in the world, Japan’s multifamily market ticks the right boxes: persistently high occupancy, stable and resilient rental income and attractively priced due to Japan’s ultra-low borrowing costs and the scope for further yield compression. 

Just as importantly, cultural factors are at play. In stark contrast to the widespread lay-offs that have swept across the US and Europe since the pandemic erupted, mass redundancies are frowned upon in Japan. Workers, moreover, were much more eager to return to the office. Both factors have underpinned the resilience of multifamily assets. “It’s an incredibly durable asset class,” said Mancini. Japan is the odd man out when it comes to the rapidly accelerating recovery in advanced economies. Yet, in the real estate investment market, it is Asia’s star performer.

(Source: South China Morning Post | Pic: Buildings – Sapporo, MIKI Yoshihito)

Related Articles

General
News
Foreign nationals with “specified skilled worker” visa status are once again entering Japan following the easing of border control measures in March related to the coronavirus. Foreign workers have sometimes waited years for permission to enter the country. Many have found employment at nursing homes, which have suffered labor shortages.
General
News
As of this year, Japan’s ecommerce market is set to be worth $150.1 billion (£105.7 billion), with a compound annual growth rate of 6.2 per cent, according to a 2020 report by JP Morgan. Meanwhile, overall Japanese retail sales rose at the fastest pace – by 5.2 per cent – in five months in March this year as consumer demand recovered from the huge hit it took from the pandemic.
General, Investors/Business
Information, News
The government and the ruling coalition are planning to extend a tax break system for people who renovate their homes, sources familiar with the matter said. The home renovation tax relief is set to expire at the end of this year but government and ruling coalition officials are considering keeping it in place until the end of 2023, the sources said. The decision to extend the program is aimed at promoting sales of used homes amid a spike in vacant homes across the country.
Investors/Business
Information
With Tokyo & Osaka approaching their pre-1990's property bubble peak, and yields in other investment hot-spots such as Fukuoka, Kyoto and Nagoya also gaining in price and becoming more compressed, opportunity-seeking investors are on the lookout for smaller cities that may still provide higher, yet stable and reliable rental returns. However, in a country as insular as Japan, where cities other than those already frequented by international visitors remain veiled in language and cultural isolation, the quest for attractive investment destinations can be difficult.